Skip to main content
Does specialist physician supply affect pediatric asthma health outcomes?
BMC Health Services Research
  • Guido Filler, Western University
  • Tom Kovesi
  • Erik Bourdon
  • Sarah Ann Jones, Western University
  • Laurentiu Givelichian
  • Cheryl Rockman-Greenberg
  • Jason Gilliland, Western University
  • Marion Williams
  • Elaine Orrbine
  • Bruno Piedboeuf
Document Type
Publication Date
URL with Digital Object Identifier


Pediatrician and pediatric subspecialist density varies substantially among the various Canadian provinces, as well as among various states in the US. It is unknown whether this variability impacts health outcomes. To study this knowledge gap, we evaluated pediatric asthma admission rates within the 2 Canadian provinces of Manitoba and Saskatchewan, which have similarly sized pediatric populations and substantially different physician densities.


This was a retrospective cross-sectional cohort study. Health regions defined by the provincial governments, have, in turn, been classified into "peer groups" by Statistics Canada, on the basis of common socio-economic characteristics and socio-demographic determinants of health. To study the relationship between the distribution of the pediatric workforce and health outcomes in Canadian children, asthma admission rates within comparable peer group regions in both provinces were examined by combining multiple national and provincial health databases. We generated physician density maps for general practitioners, and general pediatricians practicing in Manitoba and Saskatchewan in 2011.


At the provincial level, Manitoba had 48.6 pediatricians/100,000 child population, compared to 23.5/100,000 in Saskatchewan. There were 3.1 pediatric asthma specialists/100,000 child population in Manitoba and 1.4/100,000 in Saskatchewan. Among peer-group A, the differences were even more striking. A significantly higher number of patients were admitted in Saskatchewan (590.3/100,000 children) compared to Manitoba (309.3/100,000, p < 0.0001).


Saskatchewan, which has a lower pediatrician and pediatric asthma specialist supply, had a higher asthma admission rate than Manitoba. Our data suggest that there is an inverse relationship between asthma admissions and pediatrician and asthma specialist supply.


Article originally published at BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 18(1).

© 2018 Author(s)

Creative Commons License
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
Citation Information
Guido Filler, Tom Kovesi, Erik Bourdon, Sarah Ann Jones, et al.. "Does specialist physician supply affect pediatric asthma health outcomes?" BMC Health Services Research Vol. 18 Iss. 1 (2018) p. 247 - 247
Available at: