Magnesium aluminate spinel is of great interest as a transparent ceramic for its excellent mechanical properties and excellent optical transmittance. Additive manufacturing of this desirable material presents several benefits over traditional manufacturing methods, including reduced fabrication time and cost and the potential to fabricate structures with complex geometries and internal cooling networks. Despite the many benefits, the challenges hindering this technology must be overcome. A primary challenge with powder-based laser additive manufacturing of transparent ceramics is a trade-off between densification and cracking. The fabrication of transparent ceramics requires nearly full densification since pores act as light scattering centers. Even relatively small percentages of porosity render ceramics translucent or opaque. Previous studies on powder-based laser direct deposition of spinel ceramics have shown that densification to transparency is possible with high-laser power deposition. While high-laser powers are beneficial for densification, it also produces high thermal gradients that result in significant crack formation. Cracks hinder mechanical properties and transparency, limiting possible applications. Thus, we propose a filament-based deposition strategy to reduce laser power requirements. Filament-fed laser direct deposition, instead of blown powder, dramatically reduced the amount of gas porosity within the melt. Hence, highly densified, transparent, spinel ceramics were fabricated. Through decreased laser power requirements for high densification, cracking was largely reduced. This paper provides a comprehensive comparison between filament- and powder-based laser direct deposition by analyzing important sample characteristics, including porosity, cracking, grain size, and their controlling mechanisms. This paper also presents a laser direct deposition and postprocessing method to manufacture predensified spinel filaments.