Skip to main content
A Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimator of a Causal Effect on a Bounded Continuous Outcome
The International Journal of Biostatistics (2010)
  • Susan Gruber, University of California, Berkeley
  • Mark J. van der Laan, University of California, Berkeley

Targeted maximum likelihood estimation of a parameter of a data generating distribution, known to be an element of a semi-parametric model, involves constructing a parametric model through an initial density estimator with parameter ε representing an amount of fluctuation of the initial density estimator, where the score of this fluctuation model at ε = 0 equals the efficient influence curve/canonical gradient. The latter constraint can be satisfied by many parametric fluctuation models since it represents only a local constraint of its behavior at zero fluctuation. However, it is very important that the fluctuations stay within the semi-parametric model for the observed data distribution, even if the parameter can be defined on fluctuations that fall outside the assumed observed data model. In particular, in the context of sparse data, by which we mean situations where the Fisher information is low, a violation of this property can heavily affect the performance of the estimator. This paper presents a fluctuation approach that guarantees the fluctuated density estimator remains inside the bounds of the data model. We demonstrate this in the context of estimation of a causal effect of a binary treatment on a continuous outcome that is bounded. It results in a targeted maximum likelihood estimator that inherently respects known bounds, and consequently is more robust in sparse data situations than the targeted MLE using a naive fluctuation model.

When an estimation procedure incorporates weights, observations having large weights relative to the rest heavily influence the point estimate and inflate the variance. Truncating these weights is a common approach to reducing the variance, but it can also introduce bias into the estimate. We present an alternative targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) approach that dampens the effect of these heavily weighted observations. As a substitution estimator, TMLE respects the global constraints of the observed data model. For example, when outcomes are binary, a fluctuation of an initial density estimate on the logit scale constrains predicted probabilities to be between 0 and 1. This inherent enforcement of bounds has been extended to continuous outcomes. Simulation study results indicate that this approach is on a par with, and many times superior to, fluctuating on the linear scale, and in particular is more robust when there is sparsity in the data.

  • targeted maximum likelihood estimation,
  • TMLE,
  • causal effect
Publication Date
October 24, 2010
Citation Information
Susan Gruber and Mark J. van der Laan. "A Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimator of a Causal Effect on a Bounded Continuous Outcome" The International Journal of Biostatistics Vol. 6 Iss. 1 (2010)
Available at: