Skip to main content
Article
Constrained Choice: Mothers, the State, and Domestic Violence
Temple Political & Civil Rights Law Review (2015)
  • Rona Kaufman Kitchen, Duquesne University School of Law
Abstract

Mothers who are the victims of domestic violence face unique challenges in their quest for safety. The legal response to domestic violence requires that mothers respond to abuse in specific state-sanctioned manners. However, when mothers respond accordingly, such as by reporting abuse and leaving the abusive relationship, their safety and the safety of their children is not guaranteed. Moreover, by responding in state-sanctioned manners, mothers risk a host of negative consequences including increased threat to their immediate and long-term safety, the loss of their children, undesired financial, health, and social consequences, and criminal prosecution. On the other hand, when mothers respond to abuse in unsanctioned manners, such as by staying in abusive relationships, they face similarly hostile consequences including continued abuse, the loss of their children, and criminal prosecution. Thus, regardless of how mothers respond to domestic violence, they risk being harmed by their abuser and the state. As a result battered mothers’ choices are significantly constrained.

Though the legal response to domestic violence has improved dramatically over the past few decades, reforms are still needed. The state should sanction a broader range of maternal responses to domestic violence and accept greater responsibility for preventing and responding to private family violence. In addition to increasing victim safety, implementation of these reforms would increase respect for maternal autonomy and demonstrate the state’s true commitment to protecting women and children from domestic violence.

Keywords
  • mothers,
  • domestic violence,
  • intimate partner violence,
  • private family violence,
  • children,
  • criminal law,
  • gender,
  • feminist legal theory,
  • public-private dichotomy,
  • families,
  • criminal law,
  • family law,
  • constitutional law,
  • child custody,
  • divorce,
  • self-defense
Publication Date
2015
Publisher Statement
Originally published in: Temple Political & Civil Rights Law Review
Citation Information
Rona Kaufman Kitchen. "Constrained Choice: Mothers, the State, and Domestic Violence" Temple Political & Civil Rights Law Review Vol. 24 Iss. 2 (2015)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/rona_kitchen/4/