Skip to main content
Contribution to Book
The Justifications for Nondegradation Programs in U.S. Environmental Law
LE PRINCIPE DE NON-REGRÉSSION EN DROIT DE L’ENVIRONNEMENT (2012)
  • Robert L. Glicksman, George Washington University Law School
Abstract

The concept of non-regression is not one that is familiar to environmental law in the United States. Nevertheless, Congress and federal agencies have adopted programs to prevent degradation of existing high quality environments and to prevent revisions of individual emissions restrictions by making them more lenient. The first programs are known as nondegradation or anti-degradation programs. The others preclude “backsliding” by prohibiting slippage in performance by regulated entities complying with regulations that are later loosened. The nondegradation and anti-backsliding programs differ from the non-regression principle in that their justifications are not rooted in a commitment to the protection of individual rights.

This chapter explores the history and current status of nondegradation and anti-backsliding programs under U.S. water and air pollution control legislation. It describes the justifications for these programs that appear to have prompted Congress and the federal Environmental Protection Agency to adopt them. It also assesses alternative, rights-based justifications for nondegradation programs, that, while not reflected in federal environmental law in the U.S., may be supported by state constitutional and common law theories. While these theories may support rights-based nondegradation constraints in limited contexts, they are not likely to generate a broad-based set of nondegradation obligations that bind governments in the U.S.

Keywords
  • water pollution,
  • air pollution,
  • nondegradation,
  • antidegradation,
  • nonregression,
  • antibacksliding,
  • protection of high quality environmental resources,
  • environmental human rights
Disciplines
Publication Date
Spring 2012
Editor
M. Prieur & G. Sozzo
Publisher Statement
To be published as chapter in LE PRINCIPE DE NON-REGRÉSSION EN DROIT DE L’ENVIRONNEMENT (M. Prieur & G. Sozzo, eds. 2012)
Citation Information
Robert L. Glicksman. "The Justifications for Nondegradation Programs in U.S. Environmental Law" LE PRINCIPE DE NON-REGRÉSSION EN DROIT DE L’ENVIRONNEMENT (2012)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/robert_glicksman/14/