Skip to main content
Article
From the headscarf to the burqa : the role of social theorists in shaping laws against the veil
Economy and Society
  • William Peter BAEHR, Lingnan University, Hong Kong
  • Daniel GORDON, University Massachusetts, United States
Document Type
Journal article
Publication Date
5-1-2013
Keywords
  • burqa,
  • deflection of theory,
  • elongation of the political,
  • headscarf,
  • law,
  • reciprocity,
  • sociability,
  • veil
Disciplines
Abstract
Opposition to the burqa is widespread in Europe but not in the United States. What explains the difference? Focusing primarily on the French case and its Belgian facsimile, we seek to underscore the role of social theorists in legitimizing bans on the full veil. Ironically, this role has been largely disregarded by Anglophone theorists who write on the veil, and who often oppose its prohibition. This article suggests that Europe tends to be more repressive towards full veils because its political process is more open to multiple theoretical representations of the phenomenon of veiling. Conversely, the United States is more open to the provocative display of religious symbols in public because the political process is pre-structured by legal conventions that tend to filter out social theory. The push to ban the burqa in France principally derives from its brand of republicanism rather than being a product of racism and Islamophobia. Of particular significance in the French case is the emphasis on reciprocity as a political principle, a principle that is elongated into an ideal of sociability by French theorists in different disciplines. The arguments of these theorists are described, their rationale is explained and the impact of their intervention on the policy process is documented. The French case, where the popular press and legislature play a major role in shaping policy towards the burqa, is contrasted with that of the United States, where the judiciary, defending religious freedom, remains the most influential collective actor. Each country has correspondingly different attitudes to democracy. In France, the mission of democracy is to extend political equality to the social realm whereas in the United States it is religion that is prioritized so as to protect that which is deemed most sacred to the individual.
DOI
10.1080/03085147.2012.718620
E-ISSN
14695766
Publisher Statement

Copyright © 2013 Taylor & Francis

Access to external full text or publisher's version may require subscription.

Full-text Version
Publisher’s Version
Citation Information
Baehr, P., & Gordon, D. (2013). From the headscarf to the burqa: The role of social theorists in shaping laws against the veil. Economy and Society, 42(2), 249-280. doi: 10.1080/03085147.2012.718620