Skip to main content
Article
Teaching and learning guide for : cinema as philosophy
Philosophy Compass
  • Paisley Nathan LIVINGSTON, Lingnan University, Hong Kong
Document Type
Journal article
Publication Date
10-1-2010
Abstract
The idea that films can be philosophical, or in some sense ‘do’ philosophy, has recently found a number of prominent proponents. What is at stake here is generally more than the tepid claim that some documentaries about philosophy and related topics convey philosophically relevant content. Instead, the contention is that cinematic fictions, including popular movies such as The Matrix, make significant contributions to philosophy. Various more specific claims are linked to this basic idea. One, relatively weak, but pedagogically important observation is that some films can be used to provide philosophy students with vivid and thought-provoking illustrations of philosophical issues. Film screenings stimulate discussion and may motivate renewed engagement with difficult philosophical texts. A stronger contention, however, seeks to link innovative and philosophically valuable thinking to ‘the film itself’ or to the ‘specificity of the cinematic medium’. Such claims raise interesting questions, including questions about the status of the increasingly prevalent philosophically motivated interpretations of particular movies. Who is actually doing the philosophizing in such cases? Is it the audio-visual display, the film-maker, or the philosopher who devises an interpretation of the work? What is the role of specifically cinematic devices in the philosophical points made in such interpretations? Is there any tension between the goal of appreciating a film as a work of art and the goal of arguing that a film has significant implications for a position on a problem in philosophy? A course in the general area of cinema as philosophy can focus on issues related to the locus and status of cinematic philosophizing. It can also delve into specific films and film-makers and philosophically oriented interpretations of specific philosophical topics, such as personal identity. Issues pertaining to interpretation, meaning, and authorship can be usefully investigated in this connection, as can topics in meta-philosophy related to the very nature of philosophical insight or knowledge.
DOI
10.1111/j.1747-9991.2010.00285.x
E-ISSN
17479991
Publisher Statement

Copyright © 2010 The Author. Journal Compilation © 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Access to external full text or publisher's version may require subscription.

Full-text Version
Publisher’s Version
Citation Information
Livingston, P. (2010). Teaching and learning guide for: Cinema as philosophy. Philosophy Compass, 5(4), 359-362.