Skip to main content
Unpublished Paper
Law and Order on a Beer Mat: Law, Interdisciplinarity and Expertise
ExpressO (2013)
  • Nicolette M Priaulx
  • Martin Weinel, Cardiff University
Abstract

In this paper we seek to offer an original theoretical platform for thinking about the nature of legal knowledge produced through ‘legal interdisciplinarity’. The context for our discussion is the emergence of a ‘behavioural boom’ in the field of law where researchers increasingly turn to fields like behavioural economics to encourage shifts in legal and social governance architecture. Using a case study which explores the application of a sub-branch of psychology to civil law, we highlight serious concerns attending the capacity of lone legal researchers to meaningfully navigate non-legal domains. Central to our analysis, is the sociology of expertise and experience, and it is from this perspective that we explore the interdisciplinary process. Drawing attention to the extent to which largely “unwritten” practices and conventions inhabit disciplines and how these govern knowledge, we point to the insurmountable barriers confronting lone legal interdisciplinarians. We illustrate why that work, by contrast with genuine collaborative/interactional interdisciplinary research, should be regarded as lacking value from a policy/political perspective. This is not, however, to diminish the potential value of works of a non-collaborative nature. Noting the value of interdisciplinary work of a more provisional and creative character, and its critical importance to the legal project, we draw a critical distinction between interactional research and simulated research. This distinction we argue proves critical to identifying what interdisciplinary work can lend itself to policy application and that which cannot, as well as accommodating the fullest range of interdisciplinary research efforts to flourish.

Keywords
  • Legal knowledge,
  • expertise,
  • interdisciplinarity,
  • science,
  • behavior
Publication Date
September 12, 2013
Citation Information
Nicolette M Priaulx and Martin Weinel. "Law and Order on a Beer Mat: Law, Interdisciplinarity and Expertise" ExpressO (2013)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/nicolette_priaulx/1/