Skip to main content
Article
Juries in Film and Television
Criminology and Criminal Justice, Oxford Research Encyclopedias (2017)
  • Nancy Marder, Illinois Institute of Technology
Abstract
The early jury films typically portray the jury as a passive group of men who simply watch the trial with little reaction. They are meant to stand in for the viewer. The viewer, like the jury, is supposed to reach a verdict as to the defendant’s guilt or innocence. There are a few exceptions to this traditional portrayal of the jury. The exceptions involve a holdout juror who is dissatisfied with the verdict and conducts his or her own investigation. The most well known jury film, 12 Angry Men, which aired in 1957, marks a departure from these traditional and exceptional portrayals of a jury. This film is an outlier in the annals of jury films because it shows the jury at work; all the action takes place as the jury deliberates in the jury room. It also depicts an unusual scenario in which a single juror is able to stand up against the other 11 jurors and ultimately persuade them to change their votes. One reason this film has endured is that it depicts an individual’s uphill battle against a group. Another reason is that the plot has been incorporated into episodes of popular television shows so that new generations of viewers learn about it. There have been only a few modern films that focus on the jury. Some of these films return to the theme of the holdout juror who carries out a subsequent investigation to uncover the truth, whereas others show a juror who engages in misconduct or self-help in the face of a defendant who has abused the trial process. Although the focus on the holdout juror in many of these films, both old and new, provides drama, holdout jurors are hard to find in actual jury trials, especially when there are just one or two jurors who are holdouts.
Keywords
  • jury films,
  • jury trials,
  • juries,
  • jury deliberations,
  • holdout juror,
  • hung jury,
  • juror misconduct,
  • law
Disciplines
Publication Date
April 26, 2017
DOI
10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.013.186
Citation Information
Nancy Marder. "Juries in Film and Television" Criminology and Criminal Justice, Oxford Research Encyclopedias (2017)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/nancy_marder/66/