Skip to main content
Article
The Impact of Secondary Condom Interventions on the Interpretation of Results from HIV Prevention Trials
Statistical Communications in Infectious Diseases (2010)
  • Stephen Shiboski, University of California, San Francisco
  • Michael Rosenblum, Johns Hopkins University
  • Nicholas P. Jewell, University of California, Berkeley
Abstract
Given the recent failure of a number of randomized trials to demonstrate effectiveness of proposed methods for prevention of sexual transmission of HIV, novel approaches to study design and analysis that address adherence and other post-randomization behaviors are of increasing interest. The inclusion of a mandatory condom use intervention in all randomized groups in such trials can significantly impact interpretation of study results, especially when levels of use observed in the study may differ from real world levels. We use quantitative examples and simulations to investigate this issue, focusing on effectiveness estimated by the standard intention to treat analysis approach. We also assess the application of recently developed methods for estimating the causal effect of treatment assignment, accounting for observed levels of condom use. Results show that observed levels of condom use may have substantial impacts on the conclusions drawn from standard analyses of prevention trials, with the most serious effects observed in studies with unblinded control groups. Causal estimation methods accounting for post-randomization behaviors can help clarify these impacts by focusing attention on effectiveness for controlled levels of condom use. Supplemental causal analyses that account for post-randomization condom use may provide useful information about possible efficacy that complement standard analyses. However, interpretation of results may be limited by the quality of available data on adherence behavior, and limited statistical power.
Keywords
  • HIV prevention trials,
  • intention to treat,
  • causal estimation,
  • direct effect
Publication Date
April 2, 2010
Citation Information
Stephen Shiboski, Michael Rosenblum and Nicholas P. Jewell. "The Impact of Secondary Condom Interventions on the Interpretation of Results from HIV Prevention Trials" Statistical Communications in Infectious Diseases Vol. 2 Iss. 1 (2010)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/mrosenblum/7/