Skip to main content
Product and Process Modularity's Effects on Manufacturing Agility and Firm Growth Performance
Journal of Product Innovation Management
  • Mark A. Jacobs, University of Dayton
  • Cornelia Droge, The Eli Broad Graduate School of Management
  • Shawnee K. Vickery, The Eli Broad Graduate School of Management
  • Roger Calantone, Michigan State University
Document Type
Publication Date
Modularity in product design has been hailed as a way to speed new product development (NPD), to reduce NPD cost, and to enhance customization possibilities for consumers. Modularity in process design may speed new product manufacturing setup times, reduce costs, and enhance the profitability of the lower volumes that customization often entails. However, empirical evidence is scarce that either product or process modularity—individually, jointly, or sequentially—actually produce these or other proposed benefits (e.g., performance growth). This study builds on general modular systems theory (GMST) by examining the theoretical relationship between product and process modularity and the effects of each on firm growth performance. Using structural equation modeling, partial versus complete mediation by manufacturing agility is also scrutinized. In one pair of models, product modularity and process modularity are separate direct antecedents to manufacturing agility, which is modeled to affect firm growth performance; in a second pair of models, product and process modularity are related antecedents to manufacturing agility, with product modularity preceding process modularity. Results from the best-fitting model show that product modularity directly and positively affects process modularity, manufacturing agility, and firm growth performance. Process modularity was unrelated to manufacturing agility, and neither process modularity nor manufacturing agility predicted growth performance. Consistent with GMST, the study provides empirical evidence of the power of one element of a modular system to orchestrate a fit between a firm's product and manufacturing strategies and to directly drive system performance. Thus, modularity in product design is revealed as the key to understanding GMST effects concerning how changes in one system generate changes in other systems.
Inclusive pages

Permission documentation is on file.

John Wiley & Sons
Peer Reviewed
Citation Information
Mark A. Jacobs, Cornelia Droge, Shawnee K. Vickery and Roger Calantone. "Product and Process Modularity's Effects on Manufacturing Agility and Firm Growth Performance" Journal of Product Innovation Management Vol. 28 Iss. 1 (2011)
Available at: