Skip to main content
Contribution to Book
Securing Health through Rights
Incentives for Global Public Health: Patent Law and Access to Essential Medicines (2010)
  • Katharine G. Young, Boston College Law School
Abstract

The right to health is recognized in international human rights law and in many modern liberal constitutions. Yet it is notoriously difficult to conceptualize and institutionalize. It raises boundary problems in relation to the object of the right and its correlative duties, and reasonable disagreement on the values that make it worthy of protection. This article departs from the positivist attempt to define the meaning of the right to health, or the normative attempt to provide it with a settled justificatory theory. Instead, it argues that attention to a theoretically informed practical action, captured by the concept of praxis, clarifies the institutional potentials of the right to health or health care, even as it accepts its inevitable limitations. The article reveals this potential by examining two instances of health rights praxis. The first involves a defense by the Treatment Action Campaign of the regulation of medicines in South Africa. The second involves a targeted campaign and litigation against user fee health financing in Ghana. These cases demonstrate how the meaning of a legal right to health is created, challenged and changed in the effort to secure positive health outcomes.

Keywords
  • right to health,
  • economic and social rights,
  • South Africa,
  • Treatment Action Campaign,
  • Ghana,
  • Legal Resources Center,
  • patents in medicines,
  • user fees,
  • health financing,
  • practical action,
  • praxis,
  • litigation as performance
Disciplines
Publication Date
2010
Editor
Thomas Pogge, Matthew Rimmer & Kim Rubenstein, eds.
Publisher
Cambridge University Press
ISBN
9780521116565
Citation Information
Katharine G. Young. "Securing Health through Rights" New York, NYIncentives for Global Public Health: Patent Law and Access to Essential Medicines (2010)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/katharine_young/9/