Skip to main content
Article
Most soil trophic guilds increase plant growth: a meta-analytical review
Oikos
  • Andrew Kulmatiski
  • Andrew Anderson-Smith
  • Karen H. Beard, Utah State University
  • Stephen Doucette-Riise, Utah State University
  • Michael Mazzacavallo
  • Nicole E. Nolan, Utah State University
  • Ricardo A. Ramirez, Utah State University
  • John R. Stevens, Utah State University
Document Type
Article
Publisher
John Wiley & Sons Ltd
Publication Date
7-10-2014
DOI
10.1111/oik.01767
Abstract

Trophic cascades are important drivers of plant and animal abundances in aquatic and aboveground systems, but in soils trophic cascades have been thought to be of limited importance due to omnivory and other factors. Here we use a meta-analysis of 215 studies with 1526 experiments that measured plant growth responses to additions or removals of soil organisms to test how different soil trophic levels affect plant growth. Consistent with the trophic cascade hypothesis, we found that herbivores and plant pathogens (henceforth pests) decreased plant growth and that predators of pests increased plant growth. The magnitude of this trophic cascade was similar to that reported for aboveground systems. In contrast, we did not find evidence for trophic cascades in decomposer- and symbiont-based (henceforth mutualist) food chains. In these food chains, mutualists increased plant growth and predators of mutualists also increased plant growth, presumably by increasing nutrient cycling rates. Therefore, mutualists, predators of mutualists and predators of pests all increased plant growth. Further, experiments that added multiple organisms from different trophic levels also increased plant growth. As a result, across the dataset, soil organisms increased plant growth 29% and non-pest soil organisms increased plant growth 46%. Omnivory has traditionally been thought to confound soil trophic dynamics, but here we suggest that omnivory allows for a simplified perspective of soil food webs – one in which most soil organisms increase plant growth by preying on pests or increasing nutrient cycling rates. An implication of this perspective is that processes that decrease soil organism abundance (e.g. soil tillage) are likely to decrease aboveground productivity.

Synthesis

Soil foodwebs have resisted generalizations due to their diversity and interconnectedness. Here we use results from a meta-analysis to inform a simplified perspective of soil foodwebs: one in which most soil trophic guilds increase plant growth. Our review also includes the first widespread support for the presence of trophic cascades in soils.

Citation Information
Andrew Kulmatiski, Andrew Anderson-Smith, Karen H. Beard, Stephen Doucette-Riise, et al.. "Most soil trophic guilds increase plant growth: a meta-analytical review" Oikos Vol. 123 Iss. 12 (2014) p. 1409 - 1419
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/karenh_beard/189/