Stormwater ponds are engineered ecosystems designed for flood control and sediment retention in urban watersheds. They are the most commonly used stormwater control measure in the USA, but their biogeochemical processes and impacts are often overlooked. Here, we assessed the potential impact of stormwater ponds on regional carbon cycling by coupling carbon burial rates and fluxes of carbon dioxide and methane gases in five sites over an age gradient of 14–34 years. Carbon burial increased logarithmically with site age, ranging from 22 to 217 g carbon m−2 y−1, while, median floating chamber diffusive gas fluxes were 1290 g carbon dioxide m−2 y−1 and 5 g methane m−2 y−1, which, when combined as carbon dioxide equivalents, equates to 2900 g carbon dioxide eq m−2 y−1. Comparing carbon burial to gas flux reveals that stormwater ponds can be net carbon sources and need to be considered for regional and global carbon models.