Skip to main content
Article
Towards participatory communal appraisal
Community Development Journal (2001)
  • Joseph G. Bock
Abstract
In view of the persistent problem of communal violence in many developing countries, aid agencies are likely to use two different approaches in fostering social/communal harmony among groups with differing identities. One is to screen project proposals using an impact assessment tool. The other is to add a communal tension/harmony dimension to a commonly used project development methodology known as participatory rural appraisal. This article argues that using a screen for project selection is less desirable than instituting a communal tension/harmony dimension to a rigorous process of program design, which is more consistent with sound development practice.
Publication Date
April 1, 2001
DOI
10.1093/cdj/36.2.146
Publisher Statement
A preliminary version of this paper was presented at the 28th International Conference of Social
Welfare, workshop on Common Goals and Diverse Methodologies, in Jerusalem, July 7, 1998. I would
like to acknowledge the support I received from the W. K. Kellogg Foundation for a fellowship that
allowed me to focus on the role of aid agencies in conflict transformation. I am also indebted to the
staff and participants of two research and writing projects: the Local Capacities for Peace Project of
the Collaborative for Development Action, Inc. (based in Cambridge, MA); and, the Working Group on
Reconciliation of Caritas Internationalis (based in Rome). In addition, I wish to acknowledge the input
and advice of the staff of Catholic Relief Services/Pakistan Program (Islamabad, Pakistan), Catholic
Relief Services/Jerusalem–West Bank–Gaza Program (Jerusalem), Caritas/Jerusalem), Caritas/Pakis-
tan (Lahore, Pakistan), the Christian Study Centre (Rawalpindi, Pakistan), the Global Relations Depart-
ment of Catholic Relief Services (Baltimore, MD), Human Development Centre (Toba Tek Singh,
Pakistan), Orangi Pilot Project (Karachi, Pakistan), Pattan (Islamabad, Pakistan) and the St Xavier’s
Social Services Society (Ahmedabad, India).
Citation Information
Joseph G. Bock. "Towards participatory communal appraisal" Community Development Journal Vol. 36 Iss. 2 (2001) p. 146 - 153
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/joseph-bock/36/