Article
Empty Calories? A Fragment on LIS White Papers and the Political Sociology of LIS Elites
Journal of Academic Librarianship
(2020)
Abstract
White papers – reports conveying research or recommendations on a complex issue – arrive in the inboxes of academic librarians, along with an obligation to monitor them if they can help one's library or university. They seem to invariably disappoint, the written equivalent of empty calories. This paper asks: is this true? If so, how so? And why? To answer, a selection method produced a modest subset of current, topical white papers to analyze – hence this article as a fragment on recent, topical white papers. A simple discourse analysis was performed to find if there was a broad pattern the documents followed, and if a more analysis was required. A clue as to why this pattern prevailed came from criticisms of prognostications about the current pandemic (as of this writing), leading to a return to the reports: who authored them, and how they are situated in political-sociological terms in LIS discourse? The concluding findings fit with earlier analyses, suggesting much about prestige in LIS and how that is maintained, how practices are (and are not) formulated – and what that has to do with the white papers.
Keywords
- Political sociology,
- Pluralism,
- Elites,
- LIS think tanks,
- White papers
Disciplines
Publication Date
September, 2020
DOI
10.1016/j.acalib.2020.102215
Publisher Statement
This is article is published by Journal of Academic Librarianship and was reposted to the NIH Public Health Emergency COVID-19 Initiative.
On March 13, 2020, the National Science and Technology Advisors from a dozen countries, including the United States, called on publishers to voluntarily make their COVID-19 and coronavirus-related publications, and the available data supporting them, immediately accessible in PubMed Central (PMC) and other appropriate public repositories to support the ongoing public health emergency response efforts.
To date, more than fifty publishers (see Collaborators to the right) have responded to the call and volunteered to make their coronavirus-related articles accessible in PMC in formats and under license terms that facilitate text mining and secondary analysis. In addition, many other PMC journals and publishers make their coronavirus-related articles available the same way.
See the COVID-19 Initiative FAQ for more information, including details on scope and publisher eligibility.
Coronavirus-Related and COVID-19-Related Articles in PMC
Queries in PMC to find full-text journal articles relating to
- COVID-19 (all)
- Open Access only | Author Manuscripts only
- Coronaviruses broadly (historical and current literature) (all)
- Open Access only | Author Manuscripts only
You can append your own custom queries with "open access"[filter] or "author manuscript"[filter] as we have done to the queries above to identify articles that are currently available in PMC Text Mining Collections.
NLM encourages customization of the search queries suggested in the right-hand navigation bar to meet your specific research or information needs.
NLM appreciates this opportunity to work with the publishing community to accelerate global efforts to contain the SARS-CoV-2 virus. To view the complete call to publishers, see Chief Science Advisors Around the World and WHOSTP Call on Publishers to Make COVID-19 Data/Research Publicly Available.
****
PubMed Central® (PMC) is a free full-text archive of biomedical and life sciences journal literature at the U.S. National Institutes of Health's National Library of Medicine (NIH/NLM). In keeping with NLM’s legislative mandate to collect and preserve the biomedical literature, PMC serves as a digital counterpart to NLM’s extensive print journal collection that supports contemporary biomedical and health care research and practice as well as future scholarship. It is also part of the PMC International Network.
Citation Information
John Buschman. "Empty Calories? A Fragment on LIS White Papers and the Political Sociology of LIS Elites" Journal of Academic Librarianship Vol. 46 Iss. 5 (2020) ISSN: 0099-1333 Available at: http://works.bepress.com/john_buschman/92/