Skip to main content
Article
Independent Spending in State Elections, 2006–2010: Vertically Networked Political Parties Were the Real Story, Not Business
The Forum (2014)
  • Keith E. Hamm, Rice University
  • Michael J. Malbin, Rice University
  • Jaclyn J. Kettler, Rice University
  • Brendan Glavin
Abstract
This article examines independent spending in state elections before and after the Supreme Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United v. FEC. We find that the decision did not have much of a direct effect on business spending, despite public expectations. Increases were higher in the aggregate in states that prohibited corporate spending before the decision. However, the major growth was not in the business or labor sectors, but in the network organizations of political parties – and most particularly the national organizations of state elected and party officials. Contrary to some contemporary views, these developments cannot be understood as a displacement of within-state money from parties to interest groups. Instead, national party organizations were operating across state lines, deciding whether to contribute to formal party committees or their party allies as local circumstances might dictate. This complex movement of money belies any theorizing that would treat a decline in the proportional role of formal party spending as equivalent to a zero-sum increase in the non-party power of interest groups. Rather, we see the pattern of independent spending as part of a larger story of change in American political parties. These changes now include vertically networked parties operating across levels of jurisdiction, alongside the horizontal networks receiving attention in recent scholarship.
Publication Date
August, 2014
Citation Information
Keith E. Hamm, Michael J. Malbin, Jaclyn J. Kettler and Brendan Glavin. "Independent Spending in State Elections, 2006–2010: Vertically Networked Political Parties Were the Real Story, Not Business" The Forum Vol. 12 Iss. 2 (2014)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/jaclyn_kettler/4/