Skip to main content
Article
Organizational Culture, Professional Ethics, and Guantanamo
Case Western Reserve University Journal of International Law (2009)
  • Greg McNeal, Pepperdine University
Abstract
In this symposium essay I draw attention to the intersection between the social scientific literature on organizational culture and the legal ethics literature. Drawing from the organizational theory literature I detail a framework for assessing organizational culture and explain how organizational culture reflects more than rules and structure within an organization, but rather represents deeper values, practices, and ways of thinking. While organizational culture is difficult to change, it can be modified or sustained through power, status, rewards, and other mechanisms. After establishing a baseline for assessing organizational culture I highlight efforts by the Bush administration to exercise control over a military culture which was resistant to the administration’s legal policy initiatives. This effort at control manifested itself in the creation of the military commissions in 2001, an attempt to minimize the influence of military attorneys in 2003, and efforts to exercise political control over military commissions in 2006; each effort was successfully resisted by members of the military. I conclude by observing that the literature on organizational culture can provide insights into the literature on legal ethics and political control of the military specifically and political control of bureaucracies more generally.
Publication Date
2009
Citation Information
Greg McNeal. "Organizational Culture, Professional Ethics, and Guantanamo" Case Western Reserve University Journal of International Law (2009)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/gregorymcneal/20/