Skip to main content
Ad Law Incarcerated
Berkeley Journal of Criminal Law (2010)
  • Giovanna Shay

Prison and jail regulation is the administrative law of mass incarceration. Although the United States imprisons more people than any other nation, our corrections policies are a legal “no man’s land.” Scholars ignore them. Courts defer to them. States routinely exempt them from their administrative procedure act requirements. This Article focuses on the largely unexamined area of corrections regulation and makes the case for subjecting corrections policies to notice-and-comment rulemaking, or according them less deference. Corrections rules became increasingly important when the first wave of prison reform efforts produced bureaucratization of prison systems in the 1970s and early 1980s. Subsequently, incarceration rates sky-rocketed, particularly for people of color. While courts have abandoned an explicit “hands-off” policy towards prisons, they have switched instead to a posture of deference to corrections policies. As a result, prison and jail regulation is a legal regime that reinforces racial hierarchies. This Article discusses the wide range of corrections policies that affect prisoners and their families, as well as free communities. With 700,000 prisoners returning home annually, it argues, we cannot ignore prison and jail regulation, for reasons of public health and safety, if not fairness. The Article canvasses state administrative procedure acts and confirms that corrections policies are often exempt or partially exempt from rulemaking requirements. It calls for greater opportunities for democratic participation, accountability, and transparency in corrections rule-making.

  • mass incarceration,
  • administrative law,
  • prison and jail regulation
Publication Date
Winter 2010
Citation Information
Giovanna Shay. "Ad Law Incarcerated" Berkeley Journal of Criminal Law (2010)
Available at: