Skip to main content
Popular Press
The Hippocratic Myth: Why doctors are under pressure to ration care, practice politics, and compromise their promise to heal
Faculty Scholarship
  • Frank Pasquale, University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law
Document Type
Book Review
Publication Date
1-1-2011
Keywords
  • Health care regulation,
  • The Hippocratic Oath,
  • Bloche,
  • Atul Gawande’s The Checklist Manifesto
Abstract
Not many policymakers or scholars can write with the authority of Gregg Bloche. Bloche is not only a law professor, but a physician, who knows his way around a hospital. Throughout The Hippocratic Myth, Bloche cements his authority in the mind of the reader by relating stories of his experience as a clinician. In each of these stories, his humane and insightful approach as psychiatrist shines through. I do not say this to imply that Bloche uses his book to brag about his own abilities. Rather, these fluently-written passages strike one as the work of one of those rare practitioners who manages to care deeply about the patient at hand while simultaneously contextualizing the encounter in a larger framework. Thus The Hippocratic Myth should take its place among other well-received books by physicians with a sense of the big picture, including Atul Gawande’s The Checklist Manifesto and Better and Jerome Groopman’s How Doctors Think. In The Hippocratic Myth, Bloche leverages this authority to advocate for a more cost sensitive health care system, where individuals frankly acknowledge that they should expect trade-offs between cost and access to certain forms of care. My concern in this review is that Bloche the caring and expert physician would have a tough time in a health care world too deeply influenced by Bloche the cost-conscious author.
Publication Citation
32 Journal of Legal Medicine 529 (2011).
Citation Information
32 Journal of Legal Medicine 529 (2011).