Skip to main content
Article
Spatial Dynamics of Invasive Carduus Thistles
Proceedings of the 19th International Congress on Modelling and Simulation
  • E. Jongejans, Radboud University Nijmegen
  • M. R. Allen, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
  • A. E. Leib, Pennsylvania State University
  • K. M. Marchetto, Cornell University
  • N. M. Pedatella, Pennsylvania State University
  • J. Peterson-Smith, Pennsylvania State University
  • Emily S.J. Rauschert, Cleveland State University
  • D. C. Ruggiero, Pennsylvania State University
  • L. A. Russo, Pennsylvania State University
  • L. E. Ruth, Pennsylvania State University
  • Z. Sezen, University of Minnesota
  • O. Skarpaas, Norwegian Institute for Nature Research
  • B. J. Teller, Pennsylvania State University
  • L. A. Warg, University of Colorado
  • S. Yang, Pennsylvania State University
  • R. Zhang, Pennsylvania State University
  • K. Shea, Pennsylvania State University
Document Type
Conference Proceeding
Publication Date
1-1-2011
Disciplines
Abstract
We illustrate this approach for the invasive thistles Carduus acanthoides and Carduus nutans in North America, where these Eurasian plants arrived in the 19th century. The invasion routes through North America were reconstructed from a literature review: within 150 years both species have reached most US states and Canadian provinces. At the continental scale, these high invasion rates are most likely caused by human transport. However, within states the distributions are patchy. At this regional/local scale, wind dispersal of the plumed seeds is also important. Therefore, at the scale of neighboring farms, management can be informed by mechanistic population models that incorporate both wind and human dispersal. One of the foundations of a spatial population model is the local dynamics of a species. By revisiting known populations three years later, we show that initial size of C. nutans populations has a strong impact on the persistence and growth of these populations. More than fifty percent of small populations went extinct in those three years, whereas larger populations had higher persistence rates. This can be attributed to demographic stochasticity, but experimental results suggest that this can also be partly explained by reduced pollinator services in small thistle populations. Local population dynamics can be studied in more detail by following the fate of individuals and by relating the performance of individuals to their size. The resulting size-structured population models have indeed proven to be useful for studying thistle populations. Another key component of spatial population models is dispersal. We have been studying all key aspects of the dispersal process in these Carduus thistles: seed release, movement, and impact upon arrival. The seed release phase has been mainly studied in wind tunnel experiments which show that it is possible to predict the timing of seed release based on flowering phenology and weather data. Furthermore, field experiments on seed dispersal have shown that the resulting probability density kernel of dispersal distances can be well fitted by a semi-mechanistic WALD model. This allows us to simulate realistic dispersal kernels based on wind speed, turbulence, release and vegetation height, and seed terminal velocity. Now these demography and dispersal components of the spatial population dynamics need to be integrated. We have started doing so with spatially-implicit matrix and integral projection models. We expect that the field of invasion ecology will move towards more process-oriented, transparent, analytical models with increasing biological realism. Alternatively the same demography and dispersal functions can be used in spatially-explicit population models that trade tractability for the flexibility to also include the effects of heterogeneous landscape configurations and species interactions on both local population dynamics and seed dispersal.
Comments

The Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO-veni grant 863.08.006 to EJ), and the National Science Foundation of the USA (NSF grants DEB-0315860 to KS & OS and DEB-0614065 to KS & EJ) provided funding.

Citation Information
Jongejans, E., M.R. Allen, A.E. Leib, K.M. Marchetto, N.M. Pedatella, J. Peterson-Smith, E.S.J. Rauschert, D.C. Ruggiero, L.A. Russo, L.E. Ruth, Z. Sezen, O. Skarpaas, B.J. Teller, L.A. Warg, S. Yang, R. Zhang and K. Shea. (2011). Spatial dynamics of invasive Carduus thistles. Proceedings of the International Congress on Modelling and Simulation. pp. 2514-2520. ISBN: 978-0-9872143-1-7.