Skip to main content
Article
Broadband Openness Rules Are Fully Justified by Economic Research
COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGIES (2011)
  • Nicholas Economides, New York University
Abstract

This paper is an outgrowth of the filings in the FCC's broadband openness proceeding that focused on the issue of networks neutrality. Newly available data confirms that competition in the broadband access marketplace is limited. Wireless broadband access services are unlikely to act as effective economic substitutes for wireline broadband access services and instead are likely to act as a complement. Nor will competition in the Internet backbone marketplace constrain "last mile" broadband access providers. The last mile's concentrated market structure, combined with high switching costs, provides these providers with the ability to engage in practices that will reduce social welfare in the absence of open broadband rules. Allowing broadband providers to charge third party content providers will not necessarily result in lower prices being charged to residential Internet subscribers. The effect of open broadband rules on broadband provider revenues is likely to be small and can be either positive or negative. Price discrimination by broadband providers against third party applications and content providers will reduce societal welfare for numerous reasons. This reduction in societal welfare is especially acute when price discrimination is taken to the extreme of exclusive dealing imposed on content providers. Antitrust and consumer protection laws are insufficient to protect societal welfare in the absence of open broadband rules.

Keywords
  • Network neutrality,
  • Internet,
  • two-sided market,
  • discrimination,
  • prioritization,
  • market power,
  • broadband,
  • access pricing,
  • AT&T,
  • Verizon,
  • Google
Publication Date
October, 2011
Citation Information
Nicholas Economides. "Broadband Openness Rules Are Fully Justified by Economic Research" COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGIES Vol. 84 Iss. 4 (2011)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/economides/36/