Skip to main content
Article
What's so special about a special ethics for business?
Journal of Business Ethics
  • Earl W. Spurgin, John Carroll University
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
4-1-2000
Abstract

In business ethics literature, debate over a special ethics generally has framed examination of the rules governing business. By constructing a dilemma faced by proponents of a special ethics, I argue that this framing is misguided. Proponents must adopt either an insular or a derivative conception. The former, the view that business is insulated from moral rules, is problematic because arguments used to support it force proponents to accept the idea that each aspect of life is insulated from moral rules. This idea, however, renders philosophically insignificant the claim that business has a special ethics. Proponents no longer make a claim about business, but, rather, a relativistic claim about ethics in general. The derivative conception is the view that business is a set of circumstances that bear on the application of moral rules. This, however, is true of each aspect of life, and is simply an application of the principle ‘ought implies can’. The result is that there is nothing special about this sense of a special ethics. Despite lacking specialness, however, the derivative conception provides proper framing for examination of the rules governing business. It subjects business to moral rules, but, also, accounts for the challenging circumstances businesspersons face.

Comments

Published as:

Spurgin, Earl W. "What's so special about a special ethics for business?" Journal of Business Ethics 24 (2000): 273-281.

The final publication is available at link.springer.com.

DOI: 10.1023/A:1006024316092

Citation Information
Earl W. Spurgin. "What's so special about a special ethics for business?" Journal of Business Ethics (2000)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/earl_spurgin/5/