Skip to main content
Article
Some Artificial Intelligence Tools for Argument Evaluation: An Introduction
Argumentation
  • Douglas Walton, University of Windsor, Centre for Research in Reasoning, Argumentation and Rhetoric
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
1-1-2016
DOI
10.1007/s10503-015-9387
Keywords
  • Computational systems,
  • Defeasible argumentation,
  • Argument graphs,
  • Bayesian rules,
  • Schemes,
  • Audience,
  • Argument from expert opinion,
  • Carneades Argumentation System
Disciplines
Abstract

Even though tools for identifying and analyzing arguments are now in wide use in the field of argumentation studies, so far there is a paucity of resources for evaluating real arguments, aside from using deductive logic or Bayesian rules that apply to inductive arguments. In this paper it is shown that recent developments in artificial intelligence in the area of computational systems for modeling defeasible argumentation reveal a different approach that is currently making interesting progress. It is shown how these systems provide the general outlines for a system of argument evaluation that can be applied to legal arguments as well as everyday conversational arguments to assist a user to evaluate an argument.

Citation Information
Douglas Walton. "Some Artificial Intelligence Tools for Argument Evaluation: An Introduction" Argumentation (2016) p. 1 - 23
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/douglas-walton/47/