Skip to main content
Contribution to Book
A New Global Constitutional Order?
Research Handbook on Comparative Constitutional Law (2010)
  • David Schneiderman, University of Toronto
Abstract

Accompanying the rise of new transnational legal rules and institutions intended to promote global economic integration are questions about the linkages between transnational legality and constitutional law. In what ways does transnational economic law mimic features of national constitutional law? Does transnational law complement in some ways or supersede in other ways what we typically describe as constitutional law? To these questions we can now add the following: are transnational rules and institutions a proper subject of study for comparative constitutionalists? This chapter makes a case for the incorporation of forms of transnational legality into comparative constitutional studies. Taking as its focus the regime of international investment law, I argue that an appreciation of the constitutional functions of transnational legality deepen understandings of how constitutional law develops within, across, and beyond national systems of law. By distinguishing between those who promote ‘constitutionalism as project’ and those who deploy ‘constitutionalism as critique,’ we are better able to explain the phenomenon of convergence and divergence in constitutional law. This expansion of the comparativist’s toolkit of resources, though challenging conventional understandings of constitutional law as grounded exclusively in states, better captures current developments.

Keywords
  • global law,
  • constitutional law,
  • international investment law
Publication Date
2010
Editor
Rosalind Dixon and Tom Ginsburg
Publisher
Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
Citation Information
David Schneiderman. "A New Global Constitutional Order?" Research Handbook on Comparative Constitutional Law (2010)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/david_schneiderman/3/