Skip to main content
Extended Comprehensive Study of Association Measures for Fault Localization
Journal of Software: Evolution and Process
  • Lucia LUCIA, Singapore Management University
  • David LO, Singapore Management University
  • Lingxiao JIANG, Singapore Management University
  • Ferdian THUNG, Singapore Management University
  • Aditya BUDI
Publication Type
Journal Article
Publication Date
Spectrum-based fault localization is a promising approach to automatically locate root causes of failures quickly. Two well-known spectrum-based fault localization techniques, Tarantula and Ochiai, measure how likely a program element is a root cause of failures based on profiles of correct and failed program executions. These techniques are conceptually similar to association measures that have been proposed in statistics, data mining, and have been utilized to quantify the relationship strength between two variables of interest (e.g., the use of a medicine and the cure rate of a disease). In this paper, we view fault localization as a measurement of the relationship strength between the execution of program elements and program failures. We investigate the effectiveness of 40 association measures from the literature on locating bugs. Our empirical evaluations involve single-bug and multiple-bug programs. We find there is no best single measure for all cases. Klosgen and Ochiai outperform other measures for localizing single-bug programs. Although localizing multiple-bug programs, Added Value could localize the bugs with on average smallest percentage of inspected code, whereas a number of other measures have similar performance. The accuracies of the measures in localizing multi-bug programs are lower than single-bug programs, which provokes future research.
  • Association Measures,
  • Fault Localization,
  • Program Spectra
Creative Commons License
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0
Additional URL

To cite the data package, please use the following citation:

Lucia, L., Lo, D., Jiang, L., Thung, F., & Budi, A. (2014). Data from: Extended Comprehensive Study of Association Measures for Fault Localization. InK Repository at Singapore Management University.

Citation Information
Lucia LUCIA, David LO, Lingxiao JIANG, Ferdian THUNG, et al.. "Extended Comprehensive Study of Association Measures for Fault Localization" Journal of Software: Evolution and Process Vol. 26 Iss. 2 (2014) p. 172 - 219 ISSN: 2047-7481
Available at: