Skip to main content
Comparison of Alternaria measures in inner-city low-income housing by allergen assay and cultural analysis
Annals of Allergy Asthma and Immunology (2008)
  • J L Peters
  • M L Muilenberg
  • H A Burge
  • Christine A Rogers, University of Massachusetts - Amherst
  • J D Spengler

Background Sensitivity to Alternaria allergens has been associated with severe asthma and life-threatening exacerbations, and a high prevalence of Alternaria sensitivity has been reported among inner-city populations. Traditionally, epidemiologic studies have measured indoor Alternaria concentrations by cultural analyses; however, the number of viable spores may not be a good proxy for allergen levels. Furthermore, other genera share epitopes with Alternaria that may contribute to the allergenic effect. Objective To compare measures of Alternaria antigen by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with measures of Alternaria and cross-reactive genera (Ulocladium, Curvularia, Epicoccum, and Stemphylium) by cultural analysis. Method Antigen assays and cultural analyses were performed on vacuum-collected bed dust samples collected between June 18, 2002, and February 9, 2004, from 3 inner-city, low-income public housing developments. Results Alternaria antigen was found in all bed dust samples regardless of season. However, culturable Alternaria, Ulocladium, Curvularia, Epicoccum, and Stemphylium were only found in 50%, 35%, 6%, 11%, and 0% of bed samples, respectively. No correlations were found between Alternaria antigen and culturable concentrations of Alternaria or of its cross-reactive genera except for marginal correlation with Ulocladium culturable concentrations. Conclusions The results confirm that exposure to Alternaria antigens and allergens can occur even in the absence of culturable Alternaria or its cross-reactive genera, so further refinement and use of assays are essential for characterizing the distribution and determinants of indoor fungal allergen levels for sensitive populations.

Publication Date
April, 2008
Citation Information
J L Peters, M L Muilenberg, H A Burge, Christine A Rogers, et al.. "Comparison of Alternaria measures in inner-city low-income housing by allergen assay and cultural analysis" Annals of Allergy Asthma and Immunology Vol. 100 Iss. 4 (2008)
Available at: