Skip to main content
Unpublished Paper
Forensic Genetics and the Ascendancy of Modern “Race Science:” Establishing the Inadmissibility of DNA Estimates of Race
ExpressO (2008)
  • Christian B. Sundquist, Albany Law School
Abstract

The meaning of “race” has been vigorously contested throughout history. Early theories of race assigned social, intellectual, moral and physical values to perceived physical differences among groups of people. The perception that race should be defined in terms of genetic and biologic difference fueled the “race science” of the Eighteenth and Nineteenth centuries, during which time geneticists, physiognomists, eugenicists, anthropologists and others purported to find scientific justification for denying equal treatment to non-white persons. Nazi Germany applied these understandings of race in a manner which shocked the world, and following World War II the concept of race increasingly came to be understood as a socio-political construction with no biological meaning. Modern theories thus understand race as a social grouping of persons necessary to preserve unbalanced relationships of power.

Nonetheless, there has been an increased willingness of late to understand race in terms of biological difference. In particular, federal and state courts in the United States have largely embraced the use of distinct racial DNA databases to form expert opinions on racial genomic probability. Race, however, remains a purely social construct. Scientific evidence that claims the ability to biologically discern race should therefore be rejected by courts as irrelevant, unreliable and unfairly prejudicial. This Article argues that the prevailing socio-political understanding of race is being threatened by an ascendance of modern “race science,” and advocates a conception of race that accounts for the teachings of modern genetics, while avoiding a biologically reductionist view of race.

Disciplines
Publication Date
September 26, 2008
Citation Information
Christian B. Sundquist. "Forensic Genetics and the Ascendancy of Modern “Race Science:” Establishing the Inadmissibility of DNA Estimates of Race" ExpressO (2008)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/christian_sundquist/1/