Skip to main content
Diagnosing and Treating 'Insanity' on Death Row: Legal and Ethical Perspectives
Behavioral Science and the Law
  • Charles P. Ewing, University at Buffalo School of Law
Document Type
Publication Date

In every American state with a death penalty law, execution of the insane is forbidden by statute or case law. Recently, the United States Supreme Court held that this proscription is mandated by the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause of the Eighth Amendment. As a result of these laws and the Supreme Court's recent ruling, psychiatrists and psychologists have been and will continue to be called upon to both diagnose and treat insanity among death row inmates. This article considers whether psychiatrists and psychologists can meet both these legal demands and the ethical demands of the healing professions to which they belong.

Citation Information
Charles P. Ewing. "Diagnosing and Treating 'Insanity' on Death Row: Legal and Ethical Perspectives" Behavioral Science and the Law Vol. 5 Iss. 2 (1987) p. 175 - 185
Available at: