Skip to main content
Article
Thrombectomy in DAWN- and DEFUSE-3-Ineligible Patients: A Subgroup Analysis From the BEST Prospective Cohort Study
Neurosurgery
  • James E Siegler
  • Steven R Messé
  • Heidi Sucharew
  • Scott E Kasner
  • Tapan Mehta
  • Niraj Arora
  • Amy K Starosciak
  • Felipe De Los Rios La Rosa
  • Natasha R Barnhill
  • Akshitkumar M Mistry
  • Kishan Patel
  • Salman Assad
  • Amjad Tarboosh
  • Katarina Dakay
  • Sanjana Salwi
  • Jeff Wagner
  • Alicia Bennett
  • Bharathi D Jagadeesan
  • Christopher Streib
  • Stewart A Weber
  • Rohan Chitale
  • John J Volpi
  • Stephan A Mayer, Henry Ford Health
  • Shadi Yaghi
  • Mahesh Jayaraman
  • Pooja Khatri
  • Eva A Mistry
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
11-23-2019
Abstract

BACKGROUND: Because of the overwhelming benefit of thrombectomy for highly selected trial patients with large vessel occlusion (LVO), some trial-ineligible patients are being treated in practice.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the safety and efficacy of thrombectomy in DAWN/DEFUSE-3-ineligible patients.

METHODS: Using a multicenter prospective observational study of consecutive patients with anterior circulation LVO who underwent late thrombectomy, we compared symptomatic intracerebral hemorrhage (sICH) and good outcome (90-d mRS 0-2) among DAWN/DEFUSE-3-ineligible patients to trial-eligible patients and to untreated DAWN/DEFUSE-3 controls.

RESULTS: Ninety-eight patients had perfusion imaging and underwent thrombectomy >6 h; 46 (47%) were trial ineligible (41% M2 occlusions, 39% mild deficits, 28% ASPECTS <6 had poorer outcomes (aOR 0.14, 95% CI 0.05-0.44) and more sICH (aOR 24, 95% CI 5.7-103). Compared to untreated DAWN/DEFUSE-3 controls, trial-ineligible patients had more sICH (13%BEST vs 3%DAWN [P = .02] vs 4%DEFUSE [P = .05]), but were more likely to achieve a good outcome at 90 d (36%BEST vs 13%DAWN [P < .01] vs 17%DEFUSE [P = .01]).

CONCLUSION: Thrombectomy is used in practice for some patients ineligible for the DAWN/DEFUSE-3 trials with potentially favorable outcomes. Additional trials are needed to confirm the safety and efficacy of thrombectomy in broader populations, such as large core infarction and M2 occlusions.

PubMed ID
31758197
ePublication
ePub ahead of print
Citation Information
Siegler JE, Messe SR, Sucharew H, Kasner SE, Mehta T, Arora N, Starosciak AK, De Los Rios La Rosa F, Barnhill NR, Mistry AM, Patel K, Assad S, Tarboosh A, Dakay K, Salwi S, Wagner J, Bennett A, Jagadeesan BD, Streib C, Weber SA, Chitale R, Volpi JJ, Mayer SA, Yaghi S, Jayaraman M, Khatri P, and Mistry EA. Thrombectomy in DAWN- and DEFUSE-3-Ineligible Patients: A Subgroup Analysis From the BEST Prospective Cohort Study. Neurosurgery 2019.