The Pasts Fickle Shadow A California Divide over the Business Records Exception.pdfNorton Bankr. L. Advisor (2017)
In 2015, the interpretive tranquility that had come to typify the jurisprudence surrounding one of the most well-rooted hearsay exceptions—the business records one (“BRE”)—was suddenly ruptured. In that year, in Sierra Managed Asset Plan, LLC v. Hale (“Hale”) and Unifund CCR LLC v. Dear (“Unifund”), two appellate divisions of the Superior Court of California issued conflicting opinions as to whether a debt assignee may demonstrate the BRE’s elements under California Evidence Code § 1271, thereby conclusively proving its prima facie case, with no more than a declaration of the assignee’s custodian of records. Hale, soon followed by others, answered in the negative. Twice, Unifund concluded otherwise.
Despite these opinions’ state-law focus, for two reasons—in relevant part, language nearly identical to § 1271 appears in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 803(6), and both federal and state courts have long accorded some respect to each other’s interpretations of similarly-worded evidentiary strictures—uncertainty has now been cast upon a rule pivotal to the smooth operation of the Bankruptcy Code, the means by which countless claims have been proven. Brief yet exhaustive, this article dissects these opinions and explores their consequences within and without both California and bankruptcy. For these reasons, this piece may serve as a useful guide for scholars not just of bankruptcy but of hearsay, showing from where the law has come and where it may go.
It begins in ancient times for one simple reason: as elsewhere, the past must first parsed, as it sets the stage upon which text and theory clash.
- business records exception,
- Bankruptcy Rule 9017,
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,
- Rule 803(6)
Publication DateWinter January, 2017
Citation InformationAmir Shachmurove. "The Pasts Fickle Shadow A California Divide over the Business Records Exception.pdf" Norton Bankr. L. Advisor (2017) p. 1 - 14
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/amir_shachmurove/11/