Skip to main content
Article
The Characterization of Pre-insolvency Proceedings in Private International Law
European Business Organization Law Review (2020)
  • Adrian J Walters
  • Irit Mevorach, University of Nottingham
Abstract
The decade since the fnancial crisis has witnessed a proliferation of various ‘light touch’ fnancial restructuring techniques in the form of so-called pre-insolvency proceedings. These proceedings inhabit a space on the spectrum of insolvency and restructuring law, somewhere between a pure contractual workout, the domain of contract law, and a formal insolvency or rehabilitation proceeding, the domain of insolvency law. While, to date, international insolvency instruments have tended to defne insolvency proceedings quite expansively, discussion of the cross-border implications of pre-insolvency proceedings has barely begun. The question is whether pre-insolvency proceedings should qualify as proceedings related to insolvency for the purpose of private international law characterization. The risk is overinclusivity of cross-border insolvency law, which, where it is based on universality and unity, might defeat contractual expectations. This article argues, however, that we should be slow to exclude pre-insolvency proceedings from cross-border insolvency law: these proceedings are initiated in the zone of insolvency, their efectiveness depends on a statutory mandate and not purely on private ordering, they interact and intersect with formal proceedings, and can beneft from the unique system developed by cross-border insolvency law. We suggest, though, that modifed universalism (the leading norm of cross-border insolvency) and international insolvency instruments, should, and are able to, adjust to the peculiarities of preinsolvency proceedings to address concerns about inclusivity and accommodate preinsolvency proceedings adequately.
Keywords
  • law,
  • insolvency,
  • restructuring,
  • pre-solvency proceedings,
  • cross-border insolvency,
  • private international law,
  • modified universalism
Disciplines
Publication Date
February 26, 2020
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40804-020-00176-x
Citation Information
Adrian J Walters and Irit Mevorach. "The Characterization of Pre-insolvency Proceedings in Private International Law" European Business Organization Law Review Vol. 21 (2020) p. 855 - 894
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/adrian_walters/82/