Skip to main content
Article
Real-time and Historic Location Surveillance After United States v. Jones: An Administrable, Mildly Mosaic Approach
Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (2013)
  • Stephen E Henderson, University of Oklahoma College of Law
Abstract

In United States v. Jones, the government took an extreme position: so far as the federal Constitution is concerned, law enforcement can surreptitiously electronically track the movements of any American over the course of an entire month without cause or restraint. According to the government, whether the surveillance be for good reason, invidious reason, or no reason, the Fourth Amendment is not implicated. Fortunately, that position was unanimously rejected by the High Court. The Court did not, however, resolve what restriction or restraint the Fourth Amendment places upon location surveillance, reflecting a proper judicial restraint in this nuanced and difficult area. Using the newly enacted American Bar Association (ABA) Standards on Law Enforcement Access to Third Party Records, this article proposes a regulatory regime for law enforcement visual surveillance, law enforcement technologically-enhanced location surveillance, and law enforcement access to historic location records (e.g., cell site data). Ideally, the proposal would be legislatively enacted with the backdrop of constitutional judicial review, and the article comments upon the need for constructive dialogue and initiative in that process by the law enforcement community, a view influenced by six years serving as Reporter for the ABA Standards.

Keywords
  • fourth amendment,
  • us v. jones,
  • gps tracking,
  • third party doctrine,
  • location tracking,
  • location surveillance,
  • expectation of privacy,
  • search,
  • information privacy,
  • stakeout
Publication Date
2013
Citation Information
Stephen E Henderson. "Real-time and Historic Location Surveillance After United States v. Jones: An Administrable, Mildly Mosaic Approach" Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Vol. 103 Iss. 3 (2013)
Available at: http://works.bepress.com/stephen_henderson/33/