Although I work in several subfields of American politics, my overriding concern for
a number of years has been with the ability of democratic government to make intelligent
policy decisions. Stated crudely, the issue is not, who wins and who loses?--the main
preoccupation of behavioral political science for generations--but does government do
smart things or dumb things? Of course, we can't often make such categorical
distinctions; but decisions do vary with respect to their reliance on relevant evidence,
thorough analysis, careful design, and so on. I might add that this kind of concern has
been easier to explain in conversation since the first year of the Iraq War, which many
see as a calamitous mistake. I have addressed this general problem of intelligence in
policymaking--in varying degrees of depth--in relation to processes of debate and
deliberation in Congress, the competence of public opinion, advisory processes in
presidential decision making, campaign debate in elections, and the influence of public
opinion on policymaking. My main current project is about how American Government
deliberates over one the most challenging policy dilemmas it has ever faced: the conflict
between enhancing security against terrorism, on the one hand, and preserving privacy,
defendants' rights, and ultimately political freedom, on the other. In collaboration
with William Bendix, a Ph.D. candidate in US politics at the University of British
Columbia, I am working on a book that will analyze the development of policies about
wiretapping, surveillance, detention of suspects, and related issues. I have also agreed
to write a chapter on "Deliberation in Congress" for the Oxford Handbook of
Congress. Finally, I am co-editing a book that compares the US and Canadian political
systems and their performance in policymaking. The two countries have generally quite
similar societies and cultures, at least by world standards. But they have radically
different formal political institutions. Two UBC colleagues and I have assembled a
distinguished group of both American and Canadian authors and expect to produce a book
that will attract wide interest on both sides of the border. 

No subject area

PDF

A house dividing (2011)