Predictive validity of the Psychopathy Checklist: Youth Version for general and violent recidivism

Raymond R. Corrado, Simon Fraser University
Gina M. Vincent, University of Massachusetts Medical School
Stephen D. Hart, Simon Fraser University
Irwin M. Cohen, University College of the Fraser Valley

Abstract

Several authors have expressed concern regarding the use of youth psychopathy assessments in determinations of risk for general and violent offending. The Psychopathy Checklist: Youth Version (PCL:YV) was completed with 182 male adolescent offenders in this prospective study (average 14.5 month follow-up) of general and violent recidivism. Both a two-factor and three-factor model of the PCL:YV significantly predicted general and violent recidivism at a predictive accuracy ranging from 68 to 63%. However, regression analyses indicated these associations were explained primarily by behavioral psychopathic symptoms, rather than interpersonal or affective traits. Implications for the use of psychopathy assessments for risk during adolescence are discussed.