Skip to main content
Presentation
Using Sustainability Criteria for Biofuels in a Legal Context
Governing Sustainable Biofuels, Copenhagen, 19 – 20 November 2012 (2012)
  • Evgenia Pavlovskaia
Abstract

In order to analyze the empirical material of the doctoral thesis on the EU sustainability criteria for biofuels, a specially constructed model has been applied. This model has been created on the basis of two separate models of two Swedish researchers, Westerlund and Lundquist. The first component in this so-called combined model is the legal operationalization model of Staffan Westerlund, and the other is the implementation steering model of Lennart Lundquist.

Keywords
  • Sustainability criteria,
  • biofuels,
  • Directive 2009/28/EC,
  • the legal operationalization model of Staffan Westerlund,
  • the implementation steering model of Lennart Lundquist
Publication Date
Fall 2012
Citation Information
Applying the combined model of Westerlund and Lundquist helps to distinguish and explore different structural elements in the EU framework for transport biofuels and their sustainability criteria. The use of the combined model underlines that one of the most critical and vulnerable issues in the EU approach to the sustainability criteria is the issue of control of their fulfilment. One of the possible solutions to the control issue is to hire specially educated independent auditors. This is what has been recommended and promoted by EU. However, the research indicates that this control mechanism is not judicially safe, because independent auditors should also be educated and controlled. From the actor-perspective, independent auditing is not always possible to be organized at each stage of the production process. Another control mechanism that has been suggested in literature is to use self-control in self-controlling organizations. This mechanism is neither judicially safe, which means that further solutions should be looked for. Among other, more general conclusions there is an idea that sustainability criteria can efficiently be included in a legal framework with the purpose to standardize, promote and safeguard environmentally sustainable quality of products and their production methods. This can be done following various steering models and approaches.