Donald E. Shelton is the Chief Judge of the Circuit Court in Ann Arbor, Michigan and
has been on the bench for over 20 years. He is an adjunct faculty member teaching
Forensic Science Evidence at Cooley Law School and criminal justice and political science
courses at Eastern Michigan University. He received his PhD in Judicial Studies from the
University of Nevada, his M.A. in Criminology and Criminal Justice from Eastern Michigan
University, his J.D. from the University of Michigan Law School, and his B.A from Western
Michigan University. He has authored numerous books and and articles. His primary
interests include the jury system, criminal procedure, and the impact of science and
technology in the law. 

Articles

OpenURL

Ashes and Sparks Viewed from Across the Pond (book review), Critical Criminology: An International Journal (2013)

American Judge Donald Shelton reviews "Ashes and Sparks: Essays on Law and Justice" by British...

 

OpenURL

Studying Juror Expectations for Scientific Evidence: A New Model for Looking at the CSI Myth (with Gregg Barak and Young S. Kim), Court Review (2011)

This article reviews the results of two empirical studies of large groups of Michigan jurors...

 

Link

How reason for surgery and patient weight affect verdicts and perceptions in medical malpractice trials: A comparison of students and jurors (with Jenny Reichert, Monica K. Miller, and Brian H. Bornstein), Behavioral Sciences & The Law (2011)

Jurors' decision-making processes are often influenced by extra-legal factors, including judgments of defendants and plaintiffs....

 

PDF

Forensic Science Evidence and Judicial Bias in Criminal Cases, The Judges' Journal, American Bar Association (2010)

Although DNA exonerations and the NAS report have raised serious questions about the validity of...

 

Link

Juror Expectations for Scientific Evidence in Criminal Cases: Perceptions and Reality About the "CSI Effect" Myth, Thomas M. Cooley Law Review (2010)

This article originated from the author's presentation at the 2010 Cooley Law School Symposium on...

 

Books

Link

Forensic Science Evidence: Can the Law Keep Up with Science?, (2012)

Judge Shelton describes the startling questions that have arisen about the reliability of many forms...

 

Link

Forensic Science in Court: Challenges in the Twenty First Century (Issues in Crime and Justice) (2010)

Forensic Science in Court explores the legal implications of forensic science—an increasingly important and complex...

 

Contributions to Books

Forensic Science Evidence and Miscarriages of Justice, Advances in Forensic Human Identification (2014)

Discusses miscarriages of justice in forensic human identification, debating the weaknesses in seemingly reliable forensic...

 

CSI Effect, Battleground: Criminal Justice (2007)
 

Unpublished Papers

PDF

The Admissibility of Social Science Evidence in Criminal Cases (2009)

The rapid development of emerging scientific methods, especially the increased understanding of deoxyribonucleic acid ("DNA"),...

 

PDF

The Current State of Domestic Violence Courts in the United States, 2007, National Center for State Courts White Paper (2007)

This is an effort to collect, update and catalogue a list of specialized domestic violence...

 

PDF

A Database of Persons Convicted of Felonies in Washtenaw County, Michigan, 1990-2007 (2007)

This study is a database of information from Washtenaw County, Michigan, court records of approximately...

 

PDF

An Evaluation of the Status Offense Diversion Program in the Juvenile Court of Washtenaw County (2007)

The Washtenaw Juvenile Court Status Offense Diversion Program was implemented in 2002 to provide effective...

 

Presentations

• Bias in Forensic Science Evidence: From the Laboratory to the Courtroom, Essentials of Forensic Science for Legal Professionals, West Virginia University Forensic Science Initiative (2014)

Identifies and discusses bias in forensic evidence evaluations by scientists and judges

 

• The Admissibility of Human Scent Evidence: From Bloodhounds to the Body Farm (with Jose Baez), American Academy of Forensic Sciences 66th Annual Scientific Meeting (2014)

Reviews the admissibility of human scent evidence by canine detection and reviews the admissibility of...

 

Forensic Expert Bias: A Judicial Perspective, Bias in Forensics" Workshop, American Academy of Forensic Sciences 66th Annual Scientific Meeting (2014)

Identifies and discusses potential sources of bias by forensic evidence scientists and judges

 

• Can the Defense Attorney Win (or even get) an Admissibility Hearing: Daubert, the NAS Report, Inadequate Lawyering, and Biased Judges, National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (2013)

Discusses the discrepancies between prosecution and defense forensic evidence admissibility.

 

Judicial Bias and Scientific Evidence in Criminal Cases, American Academy of Forensic Sciences 65th Annual Scientific Meeting (2013)

Discusses the causes of judicial bias in the admission of forensic science evidence